Today I thought we’d do something different instead of question of the day. The UK’s ONS (Office for National Statistics) has released baby name statistics for England and Wales this week, which I always find interesting to look through as a name nerd, regardless of a country really as long as I have some sort of an idea what’s been popular there, and I also like to read what other people who are into it think of any changes in baby naming trends based on such statistics, ‘cause myself being near-dyscalculic I usually won’t notice a lot of stuff that might be going on. And I saw that on one of the larger naming websites – Nameberry – someone put together names from the top 100 for England and Wales together with those for the US so that people could vote which names for each rank they like more.
So I thought we could do a similar thing here, except to make it a bit different I decided to put English names against Welsh. In situations where a name ranks the same in both England and Wales, I pick a name of equivalent rank from Scotland, although sometimes names rank the same in all three countries like Olivia is #1 or Isla is #3 everywhere so then I just skip it. The first name in each set is from England and the other from Wales, and if a name ranks the same in both countries I’ll write (SC) after the other to indicate that it ranks on the equivalent position in Scotland.
For now I just did it with girls’ names, but I can do the boys’ as well if people end up liking this and/or if I’ll feel like it. Feel free to comment on why you chose one name over the other or what you think of them in as much or little detail as you wish, or not to comment at all and just list them, it’s up to you.
Here we go:
- Amelia or Emily (SC)?
- Ava or Freya?
- Ivy or Ella (SC)?
- Florence or Rosie?
- Lily or Ava?
- Freya or Grace?
- Mia or Lily?
- Willow or Evie?
- Sophia or Mia?
- Isabella or Ella?
- Rosie or Elsie?
- Grace or Willow?
- Sienna or Florence?
- Daisy or Evie (SC)?
- Poppy or Evelyn?
- Elsie or Phoebe?
- Emily or Millie?
- Ella or Erin?
- Evelyn or Sophia?
- Sofia or Mila?
- Charlotte or Isabella?
- Phoebe or Poppy?
- Evie or Emily?
- Harper or Maya (SC)?
- Maya or Hallie?
- Millie or Lottie?
- Matilda or Isabelle?
- Sophie or Sofia?
- Alice or Sienna?
- Emilia or Bonnie?
- Ruby or Aurora?
- Isabelle or Aria?
- Luna or Penelope?
- Maisie or Charlotte?
- Aria or Maisie?
- Penelope or Alys?
- Bonnie or Ffion?
- Eva or Imogen?
- Mila or Ruby?
- Eliza or Seren?
- Ada or Luna?
- Violet or Mali?
- Hallie or Violet?
- Arabella or Matilda?
- Esme or Zara (SC)?
- Jessica or Thea?
- Delilah or Eira?
- Imogen or Nancy?
- Chloe or Emilia?
- Eleanor or Ada?
- Lottie or Layla?
- Layla or Mabel?
- Margot or Ayla?
- Thea or Eva?
- Aurora or Alice?
- Elizabeth or Eliza?
- Mabel or Gracie?
- Emma or Nansi?
- Scarlett or Lola?
- Erin or Sophie?
- Harriet or Jessica?
- Rose or Lyra?
- Lola or Megan?
- Orla or Delilah?
- Ayla or Efa?
- Nancy or Harriet?
- Zara or Lilly?
- Iris or Mabli?
- Bella or Maya?
- Robyn or Iona (SC)?
- Molly or Scarlett?
- Maria or Cadi?
- Olive or Molly?
- Lyla or Orla?
- Maeve or Eleanor?
- Ellie or Frankie?
- Maryam or Chloe?
- Darcie or Myla?
- Heidi or Lili?
- Edith or Lyla?
- Gracie or Nia?
- Lyra or Maeve?
- Amelie or Martha?
- Lucy or Autumn?
- Hannah or Eleri?
- Myla or Harlow?
- Amber or Maddison?
- Jasmine or Amber?
- Summer or Eden?
- Eden or Iris?
- Clara or Lucy?
- Elodie or Nevaeh?
- Holly or Olive?
- Anna or Zara?
- Lara or Arabella?
- Lilly or Bella?
- Beatrice or Darcie?
- Sara or Elodie?
- Esmae or Mollie?
Bibiel’s picks:
This is gonna be so tough, I like so many of these to bits. 😀
- Amelia or Emily (SC)? Amelia. It’s been very popular over here for girls around Sophie’s age and for babies, so I don’t like it nearly as much as I did when I was younger, but Emily seems more boring and overused to me even if not in my country. Even my liking for Emily Byrd Starr doesn’t make me like Emily more than Amelia.
- Ava or Freya? Of course Freya. I love Freya, and I dislike Ava.
- Ivy or Ella (SC)? Ella, even though it’s so popular around the Anglosphere. Not a fan of Ivy.
- Florence or Rosie? Both are extremely sweet and I love them. But I think I love the sound of Rosie more.
- Lily or Ava? Lily ‘cause I don’t like Ava. Lil- names are extremely overused here so Lily feels boring, but I can’t say I dislike it.
- Freya or Grace? Freya, Grace isn’t overly interesting.
- Mia or Lily? Mia, I like the sound.
- Willow or Evie? Willow, I think it could make a sweet nickname for Wilhelmina.
- Sophia or Mia? Hm, Sophia I guess…? I like both, but at the same time I seem to see Sophia everywhere so Mia feels more interesting, while on the other hand Mia is so short that it feels incomplete compared with Sophia. But yeah, Sophia, I think.
- Isabella or Ella? Isabella, you can call her Ella anyway and have other possibilities included as well, it makes more sense as a full name to me, and I also happen to like it a lot.
- Rosie or Elsie? Awww, Elsie.
- Grace or Willow? Willow.
- Sienna or Florence? Florence, don’t like Sienna.
- Daisy or Evie (SC)? Daisy I guess, though feel kind of ambivalent towards both.
- Poppy or Evelyn? Oh my flip… … … 🤔 OK, Evelyn. But I love Poppy so so much as well.
- Elsie or Phoebe? Elsie, though Phoebe is sweet.
- Emily or Millie? Millie, although if I had to choose between those two for a real life child I’d go with Emily because of what I said re Isabella and Ella.
- Ella or Erin? I like both, but Erin is more interesting. And Celtic.
- Evelyn or Sophia? As much as I love Sophia, Evelyn is far more intriguing.
- Sofia or Mila? Hm… Mila I guess? But I really don’t know, ask me in five minutes and I’ll say Sofia.
- Charlotte or Isabella? Isabella. I should like Charlotte because I generally like names like that but I just don’t, for some reason.
- Phoebe or Poppy? Poppy!
- Evie or Emily? Emily ‘cause I just like it more than Evie even if I see fewer Evies.
- Harper or Maya (SC)? Maya, not too big on surname/unisex names although Harper isn’t very bad.
- Maya or Hallie? Maya again.
- Millie or Lottie? Millie for sure.
- Matilda or Isabelle? Isabelle for sure, but nothing at all against Matilda.
- Sophie or Sofia? Sophie, I think, but I’m very changeable with Sophie names.
- Alice or Sienna? Alice. It may be plain but it has something really cool about it.
- Emilia or Bonnie? Emilia, don’t like Bonnie.
- Ruby or Aurora? Ruby, gem stones are so cool.
- Isabelle or Aria? Isabelle.
- Luna or Penelope? I like both, but so many pets around the world seem to be called Luna these days, and then there’s Soy Luna that Sofi likes, so I think Penelope wins. It’s really nice as well, feels very sophisticated and you can call her Poppy or Nellie which are both nicknames that I like. Only the name meaning isn’t quite as cool as Luna’s since Penelope means duck.
- Maisie or Charlotte? Maisie is lovely.
- Aria or Maisie? Maisie, totally neutral about Aria.
- Penelope or Alys? Penelope, but Alys is cool too and makes me think of Alys Williams and her voice immediately.
- Bonnie or Ffion? Ffion is so cute. And no, it isn’t Welsh for Fiona, it means foxglove in Welsh.
- Eva or Imogen? I don’t like Eva, so Imogen. Imogen has something slightly quirky about it that I like.
- Mila or Ruby? Mila.
- Eliza or Seren? I love Eliza, but especially pronounced our Polish way – e-LEE-zah. –
- Ada or Luna? Luna, don’t like Ada.
- Violet or Mali? Mali, but only because of nice associations with this name, as I’m quite neutral about both of them as such.
- Hallie or Violet? Hallie.
- Arabella or Matilda? I really like Arabella.
- Esme or Zara (SC)? Zara I think. Esme and variations on the theme are too Twilight.
- Jessica or Thea? Jessica.
- Delilah or Eira? Hmmmm… If it was for a real life kid, then definitely Eira. Otherwise Delilah.
- Imogen or Nancy? Imogen.
- Chloe or Emilia? Chloe is cute.
- Eleanor or Ada? I really like Eleanor.
- Lottie or Layla? Lottie.
- Layla or Mabel? Mabel is pretty cool.
- Margot or Ayla? Ayla, though neither feels thrilling.
- Thea or Eva? Thea.
- Aurora or Alice? Alice.
- Elizabeth or Eliza? I love both, but Eliza wins.
- Mabel or Gracie? Mabel, though Gracie is nice too.
- Emma or Nansi? Nansi, but solely because Emma is so popular in the US so I see it all the time.
- Scarlett or Lola? I think Lola, ‘cause for some reason I don’t really like Scarlett that much, but then I don’t particularly love Lola either.
- Erin or Sophie? 🤔 Erin…? Yeah Erin. But Sophie is sweet.
- Harriet or Jessica? Jessica, though I quite like Harriet too.
- Rose or Lyra? Rose.
- Lola or Megan? I like the Welsh feel of Megan.
- Orla or Delilah? Delilah.
- Ayla or Efa? Ayla, but both are meh.
- Nancy or Harriet? Harriet.
- Zara or Lilly? Lilly.
- Iris or Mabli? Iris.
- Bella or Maya? Bella I guess…
- Robyn or Iona (SC)? Iona. I really like Robin for both genders, but Robyn not really, and Iona is so Scottish.
- Molly or Scarlett? Molly.
- Maria or Cadi? I have a lot of fun associations with Cadi, but it feels so nickname-y so even though Maria is very common around the world, I choose Maria. It has more of a character than Cadi.
- Olive or Molly? I like olives, yay! 😀 If it was Olivia and Molly I’d probably choose Molly, but Olive feels very cool and unusual and not quite so omnipresent as Olivia.
- Lyla or Orla? Orla definitely.
- Maeve or Eleanor? Eleanor, even though Maeve’s very close.
- Ellie or Frankie? Ellie, I don’t like Frankie for either gender while I really like Ellie.
- Maryam or Chloe? Chloe.
- Darcie or Myla? I guess Myla, but neither is my thing.
- Heidi or Lili? Heidi.
- Edith or Lyla? Lyla ‘cause I dislike Edith.
- Gracie or Nia? Nia.
- Lyra or Maeve? Maeve.
- Amelie or Martha? Amelie is even better than Amelia.
- Lucy or Autumn? I really like Lucy.
- Hannah or Eleri? LOVE Eleri. Hannah’s slightly dull.
- Myla or Harlow? Myla, ‘cause Harlow is even worse.
- Amber or Maddison? Amber.
- Jasmine or Amber? Jasmine.
- Summer or Eden? Summer, don’t like Eden one bit.
- Eden or Iris? Iris, of course.
- Clara or Lucy? Lucy, even despite all my liking for Clara.
- Elodie or Nevaeh? Lol, it’s like asking a kid whether they prefer their favourite ice cream flavour or cold overcooked brussel sprouts. Of course Elodie! 🙂
- Holly or Olive? Olives are yummy.
- Anna or Zara? I love Anna.
- Lara or Arabella? Arabella.
- Lilly or Bella? Bella.
- Beatrice or Darcie? Beatrice.
- Sara or Elodie? Elodie.
- Esmae or Mollie? Mollie.
So, how about you? Any thoughts on these in general welcome as well. 🙂