Question of the day.

If someone you loved was killed in front of you, but someone created a copy of them that was perfect right down to the atomic level, would they be the same person and would you love them just as much?

My answer:

My first thought in reaction to that question: that would be creepy! 😀 But Sofi says I’ve been overusing the word creepy lately (which is true because since my last sensory anxiety episode everything still seems kinda creepy) so I should probably come up with something more original. Okay… um… I don’t know really. 😀 I mean, I guess it’s the sort of situation where you’d have to actually experience it to know what it feels like and what you’d think about it.

I often think that I’d like if cloning animals was a legal thing to do, because then I could pay any money for someone to clone Misha for me, but on the other hand even my own conscience is against it so I’m feeling very conflicted about it and would never actually do it even if someone came to me offering to do it, if it was legal and if I had the money.

With humans it would be even more of a problem. I had a brief period when I got interested in cloning after reading Mary Modern by Camille DeAngelis, about a woman who decided to clone her own grandma. It was ages ago so I don’t remember the plot line very well now, but what comes to my mind now is that while she wanted to get her back as her grandma, that is at the age at which she knew her, the genetic material she had available was of her grandma at a much younger age. So, while you could consider her the same person physically, she was actually a different person than the one her granddaughter knew.

Also there is that quote saying that “No man ever steps in the same river twice, for it’s not the same river and he’s not the same man.”. How would that new person be the same as the one I lost if we always change?

Also cloned people don’t have a soul. Surely that would be seen somehow in that new person’s behaviour or something, or even if not, that would make them different. It just evades my mind how can someone be death and then someone else can be put in their place who would be exactly identical in all spheres – well, except for not having a soul. –

Maybe if I didn’t see any huge differences I would be able to love them in a similar way I did the original person, but I am pretty sure when thinking of it now that they would be like two distinct people in my mind. Perhaps incredibly similar, almost indistinguishably, maybe somehow not distinguishable at all in a straightforward way, but still distinct.

What do you think? 🙂

8 thoughts on “Question of the day.”

  1. A resounding NO. For myself alone of course. Some others might find the idea of a clone (and that’s what the idea is) acceptable and be very grateful to have their loved one returned to them that way. Me? I couldn’t get the image of the death out of my head and so any ‘substitute’ however perfect, wouldn’t do.

    Liked by 2 people

  2. Yeah, I’m thinking like you are on this one! Even if a clone did have a soul, would that clone have the same soul as his counterpart, or a different soul? If any of us had chosen a different lifetime, or had a different soul choose our lifetime (if that makes any sense), there’d be a disparity in how our life would be lived by a soul with a different skill set. But anyway, if you have a different soul with a clone, then it would be a different connection with the clone. I agree that the whole concept is creepy, because we know people as their souls on some level, and for that to be switched out would just be wrong somehow.

    Liked by 2 people

  3. I agree on the creepy factor. I’d say that regardless of how alike the clone was, there wouldn’t be the same shared experience. Even if their identical twin was substituted, with the same DNA, it’s not the same person.

    Liked by 2 people

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.